Ever since mankind (and womankind) could first argue, no doubt it was about this issue... or should I say tissue. Take the poll and let's settle this once and for all.

There are pros and cons to both.

Over

  • Easier to grab and rip
  • Easier to roll to the needed amount
  • It just looks like the way it should be

Under

  • It keeps your cat from rolling it all off
  • Keep it discreet
  • Some find this way easier to rip the paper

 
Me? I'm honestly one of the few that doesn't mind either way. I do add more toilet paper to the over position, but if it's under I'm not OCD enough to change it back like some would.