TL;DR Version: Take the poll below to vote for your favorite BEST tasting pizza crust in the Yakima Valley.


Pizza History in the Yakima Valley

Best Tasting Pizza Crust

From the info I could find online, it seems the oldest running pizza joint in the Yakima Valley that is still open is Magic’s Pizza Shack located in Selah. They opened in 1977 and have been operating for some 46 years!

The next oldest is Abby’s Legendary Pizza in Yakima, which opened its doors in 1983.

Doc’s Pizza in Granger opened in 1994.

Shout out to my homie, the Stonehenge Tavern in Zillah (RIP 2022). I got to eat their pizza only once, back in the mid-2000s, but I remember it was some of the best tasting pizza I’d ever had. I couldn’t locate exactly when the Stonehenge opened up as a tavern offering pizza. (I did find out, however, that in the 50’s, the building used to be Pastime Tavern & Barber Shop, and before that it was a car mechanic shop named Harvey’s Garage.) The building was destroyed in an accidental fire last year.

94.5 KATS logo
Get our free mobile app

The Ultimate Guide to Pizza Crust

Best Tasting Pizza Crust Yakima Valley POLL

In my opinion, what makes a pizza crust taste the BEST is the amount of butter, salt, and sometimes garlic added or brushed over the top of the crust once it's fully baked. It must be thick, but not hard and crunchy, unless you are ordering a thin-crust pizza. The pizza crust must be easy to chew, and not tough!

"The perfect pizza crust in the Yakima Valley must have the perfect hint of sweetness from the dough, with the perfect balance of crispy and chewy layers that take you to FLAVORTOWN!" - Something that Guy Fieri would probably say on the Food Network.

Vote for the Best Tasting Pizza Crust Yakima Valley

My favorite pizza crust in the Yakima Valley is Round Table Pizza. There’s something about the savory flavors that makes me crazy and hunger for more! What is it that they put in their pizza crust that makes it so freaking yummy? It wasn't listed in the poll we did on our "radio sister" station's Facebook page, but all of my other favorite pizza crusts were.

Vote - Best Tasting Pizza Crust in the Yakima Valley

Take the poll and let us know who you think has the best tasting pizza crust in the Yakima Valley.


94.5 KATS logo
Get our free mobile app

Report a typo or correction

Got a news tip? Email us here.

LOOK: Do you know these iconic quotes from '70s TV shows

Stacker looked through the vast array of groundbreaking 1970s television and identified 25 of its most iconic (and most memorable) quotes. 

WOAH: 99 Signs You Were a Teenager in the '90s

Grab your Hypercolor T-Shirt and Bonnie Bell Lip Smackers because we're traveling in time to the most radical decade of them all. Only real '90s teens will remember these iconic pop culture moments--see how many you recall!

LOOK: Best Beers From Every State

To find the best beer in each state and Washington D.C., Stacker analyzed January 2020 data from BeerAdvocate, a website that gathers user scores for beer in real-time. BeerAdvocate makes its determinations by compiling consumer ratings for all 50 states and Washington D.C. and applying a weighted rank to each. The weighted rank pulls the beer toward the list's average based on the number of ratings it has and aims to allow lesser-known beers to increase in rank. Only beers with at least 10 rankings to be considered; we took it a step further to only include beers with at least 100 user rankings in our gallery. Keep reading to find out what the best beer is in each of the 50 states and Washington D.C.

50 Most Popular Chain Restaurants in America

YouGov investigated the most popular dining brands in the country, and Stacker compiled the list to give readers context on the findings. Read on to look through America's vast and divergent variety of restaurants—maybe you'll even find a favorite or two.

Take a Pic of Yourself in Yakima at One of these 74 Mural Selfie Walls

Did you know that the city of Yakima, Washington, has over seventy-four (74) murals that would make for a fantastic place to get your sightseeing selfie? You've no doubt taken quite a few selfies in front of popular landmarks and selfie wallls.

Keep your eyes out for one of our unique photo-op murals to add to your collection in your social media pics, and stop and take a memorable selfie of yourself in the heart of Yakima!

More From 94.5 KATS